My Real Estate Blog

Do Realtors make too much money? Controversial I know but let's look at the numbers. Main Photo

Do Realtors make too much money? Controversial I know but let's look at the numbers.


Not too crazy to talk about
Posted: January 20, 2020 by Kathleen Taylor

Brace yourself this could be dreadfully boring! Is it the elephant in the room? It usually is when your signing contracts to list your home. Let me paint a picture from my side of the fence. Why don’t I start with an easy (lol) or maybe not so easy explanation of the commission breakdown. Possibly a better term of the commission breakdown is a boring big fat yawn of the commission breakdown. Numbers, when its a subject of money out of your pocket is none the less a topic for discussion. I’ve read lots of blog posts regarding this topic but never from a Canadian Real Estate Agents or a the very least because I’m not so sure how it works in other parts of the Country’s point of view. So here we are, and keep in mind, this is presuming an agent makes 12 deals a year or one per month which is an average presumption.

House price: $300,000 ( not far-fetched in the Niagara market where the average home price is under $402,000)

Commission: x 2.5% = $7500.00

Gross Commission Income or GCI

$7500.00- broker split (can range) average at 80/20 so $7500.00-20%=$6000.00

Broker also usually takes a flat fee off the top for a certain # of deals per year let’s say average $700.00 for the first 8 deals so…. $6000.00-$700.00= $5300.00

Next hand in the pot is Corporate. Most brands have Corporate fees. They use these fees for advertising, in-house education and training, and more things I’m not really certain about () In my case I give $2500.00 per year. This comes off at a certain percentage on each deal until it’s paid so you could have this paid in the first few months or not at all depending on your number of sales and the GCI of that sale. For this example I will make it easy and split it over 12 months so $2500.00/12=$208.00 per-month (off transactions) that’s assuming you sell a deal per month. If not it may go on your office bills. Yes another hand in the pot I will breakdown next.

Take the GCI number which is now down to $5300.00-$208.00= $5092.00

Office bills: they range but can spread anywhere from 50$ per month to $1000.00 or more depending on the office you’re in, how many thugs (oops thats a typo but a fitting one so I’m leaving it!) you pay for in your office ie: faxes, front desk staff, paper, copies, ad copies, ad sets for marketing, an actual office, and on and on and on. In my office my Broker is not a greedy little troll! More over he is a fair guy who just wants us all to succeed. I’ve never seen my office bills over $200.00. They are usually $100.00 or under. I have colleagues in the business with other brands who pay $700-800 for an average monthly office bill. Crazy I know and not sure why they do it. Color Blue I say!

Blue is Coldwell Banker

So back to the GCI number that is down to $5092.00-$100.00=$4992.00

The next place that dwindles away at my income isprofessional fees. Those would be things like Errors and Omissions insurance, Local Board Dues, National licencing fees, and if you choose to advertise your home on a not so local real estate board ie: Toronto (TREB) then you are paying dues there as well. (on a side note, which really should be another blog post! NAR which is Niagara Association of Realtors and TREB both load to theRealtor.ca so no matter where your agent lists your home that being NAR or TREB or both, it’s going to Realtor.ca. So my premise is that if someone has hydro in their home they then therefore will see your listing ANYWHERE IN THE WORLD!) Just be patient and wait the allotted time required for the home to be live on MLS.

Ok back to the “elephant” of commission. where were we? right, the GCI is down to $4992.00 and we are now taking of professional fees. for the sake of fewer numbers I’ve lumped them together (Errors and Omissions insurance, Local Board Dues, National licensing fees, and TREB) divided by 12 (assuming you do 1 deal per month /12 months) your GCI is now $4692.00

Advertising, lets talk advertising because we do a lot of personal branding which I believe isn’t part of the actual cost of listing a home so I will try to break down the cost of advertising per listing not as a whole for my personal branding. I give every listing the same deal. Some are just more expensive because of size. For Example, the Photographer and Stager charge based on square footage of the home. For this breakdown, I have been basing the GCI on $300,00.00 which most certainly is a home under 2500 sq feet so the numbers will be as follows.

Photos $300.00

Staging Consultation $275.00

Drone and/or Video footage $500.00

Signs/ riders/ directional/ etc I will average at $150.00 per listing. Once again this is broken down because you generally reuse your signs.

Print Ads/online marketing/targeted social media marketing approximately $150.00 per listing per month. This online marketing portion includes a percentage of a personal web page which is a large driving force of leads to the home and I believe ranks up there with the social media advertising. Again another Blog topic and I get all crazy talking about those numbers!

Numbers in for advertising per listing range 1375.00 per listing per month. Now i will be generous and say that not every listing requires drone footage so lets remove the $500.00 for drone shots and drop advertising to $875.00.

GCI is at $4692.00 – $875.00= $3817.00

My favorite is the tax man oh ya the tax man. This is where I could say that the deduction depends on your income and expenses. For example, if you make more than $125,000 GCI your paying the tax man more than if you only sold 2 houses that year and your GCI is under $25,000.00. for the purpose of this blog and the numbers, we are using $300,000.00 at one per month for 12 months. That will give you a GCI of approx $90,000.00 so you are in the higher portion of the tax brackets. i will guess that you will be paying 30%. Take the last GCI $3817.00-30%  = $2671.90

AND the verdict is in, 1 listing at $300,000.00 should make the average Niagara agent approx $2671.90. lets look at the timeline that is accrued with one listing.

First meeting prep: 2 hrs

First meeting: 2 hrs

Meet stager for consult: 1.5 hrs

Listing signing: 2 hrs

Meet photographer: 1.5 hrs

Administration for pre listing: 3 hrs

Marketing prep: 3 hrs

Random Buyer meetings directly related to listing: 3 hrs

Responding to calls, texts, PM’s, emails, pages, etc etc etc: 3.5 hrs

Offers and Offer related time constraints: 4 hrs or more

Post offer Administration: 2.5 hrs

Post Offer calls, texts, PM’s, email, pages etc: 3 hrs

Post Offer tidying up ie: pick up signs, post marketing, Buyer or Buyers agent  follow-up prior to closing and finally closing: 3 hrs

Grand total 34 hrs per listing minimum. These numbers would fluctuate depending on the number of inquiries or offers on a property.

Well, that was a bunch of bull! We make money there is no doubt about it. We work long hours, never get time off, always have our phones on and are always available, never fully and truly get a vacation, quiet down time or the ability to just not respond to those unlimited numbers of calls, texts, emails, personal messages, or office pages.

I tell my friends, who now know, If you were paying me thousands of dollars to sell your home would you want to go to voicemail? Oh and p.s my kids would be amazing Real Estate Agents considering they have grown up with me and my phone!

The underlying question remains, how many of us actually succeed in making money?  PM me, if I find it amongst the trillions of red dots on my Iphone I may respond and answer wink wink!

Loading Comments